Chronicles – “We will change the way the country is governed,” said Brazil’s incumbent leftist president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva late Sunday evening, after that country’s official second-round election results appeared to show him defeating challenger Flávio Bolsonaro, son of jailed former president and Lula’s 2022 opponent Jair Bolsonaro, by about 3.6 percent, or 4.4 million votes.
Lula did not say how he wants to change the government of his country, which he has already led for three presidential terms, interrupted by a 19-month stint in prison following his conviction in 2017 on corruption and money laundering charges. But his apparent victory was unanticipated, to say the least. In the first round of voting, held on Oct. 4, Bolsonaro had prevailed with a plurality of just over 47 percent, versus Lula’s 45 percent, an advantage of about 2.2 million votes, but a result requiring a runoff to secure the majority.
While a historic upset is theoretically possible, in Brazil’s modern democratic history no leading first-round candidate has ever lost in the second round. If this year’s official second-round results are accurate, that means that a staggering 10.3 million more Brazilian voters cast their ballots for Lula in the second round than did on Oct. 4. This would also mean that while Bolsonaro, the leading candidate until about an hour before the final results were announced, only picked up another 3.7 million.
In the intervening three weeks, there was no political bombshell or “October surprise”-like event that appeared to have motivated any shift in candidate preference toward or away from either candidate. No polling data tracked any decline in Bolsonaro’s winning position or indicated any uptick for Lula. Lula’s supporters at home and abroad seemed resigned to his ultimate defeat. Brazil’s economy under Lula—the most important campaign issue—has languished with 4.6 percent inflation, 13.75 percent interest rates, and mandatory government spending consuming over 92 percent of the national budget. In a regional “conservative wave” persisting over the last three years, seven other Latin American countries with similar economic and social problems have elected pro-Trump national populist presidents similar to Bolsonaro and his father over anti-Trump socialist candidates similar to Lula.
Alongside Bolsonaro’s purported second-round defeat, Brazil’s simultaneously held legislative and federal state elections registered historically strong results for his Liberal Party, which has emerged as the largest party in both houses of Brazil’s Congress, while Lula’s Marxist Workers’ Party lost considerable ground. Between the two voting rounds, most of the lesser first-round presidential candidates rallied to Bolsonaro. And even if they had not, the math behind the official results suggests that if every single first-round voter for those other candidates had backed Lula, he would still have lost by about 1.3 million votes. Indeed, until about the last hour of balloting, the incoming final results suggested a decisive victory for Bolsonaro before a statistically anomalous surge in ballots for Lula suddenly propelled the incumbent to his purported last-minute victory.
Enough circumstantial evidence has already emerged for Bolsonaro to challenge the results, which he called “unacceptable,” the result of a “dirty trick,” and “changing the rules of the game in the middle of the game.” Bypassing Brazil’s independent electoral court, a judicial body that deals exclusively with voting issues, Brazilian Supreme Court Justice Cristiano Zanin issued an order just as the polls were scheduled to close at 5 p.m. to extend balloting by an additional two hours. The order came in response to a request for the extension from Lula’s Worker’s Party, which claimed that voter services were impaired in parts of Brazil where his support is stronger.
The constitutional legality of Zanin’s order sounds questionable given the separation of function among Brazil’s judicial bodies. It appears to have arrived in many polling places after the official closing time, creating confusion and raising the question of why those polling were still open after 5 p.m. even in the absence of a judicial order. Zanin issued an additional order to restrict his first order only to polling stations that had not closed—thereby admitting that many of them had remained open after the originally scheduled closing time—and suspended all ballot counting. In some places, Zanin’s orders created what The Wall Street Journal described in its initial reports as “chaos.”
Before Lula appointed Zanin to the country’s highest court in 2023, Zanin worked as the leftist incumbent’s criminal defense attorney in the prosecutions that sent Lula to prison. Zanin later played an instrumental role in having Lula’s criminal convictions quashed on technicalities so that he would again be eligible to run for president. When Lula ran against the elder Bolsonaro in 2022, Zanin coordinated Lula’s campaign and then advised his presidential transition team on legal affairs. Zanin, it may not surprise anyone to learn, also happens to be the author of a legal text titled Lawfare: An Introduction, which examines “the strategic use of Law for political, geopolitical, military and commercial objectives.” Indeed.
Within minutes of the victory announcement and prior to the results’ official certification, global legacy media and leaders favorable to Lula—ranging from Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum to EU President Ursula von der Leyen to U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders to George Soros’s son and ideological heir, Alexander—uniformly hailed his victory as an accomplished fact, made little or no mention of the last-minute irregularities, and celebrated the apparent victory as a triumph for democracy. The New York Times’s morning-after coverage blamed Bolsonaro for objecting to the results, claiming that by doing so he is “increasing the risk of unrest.”
Brazil’s courts are dominated by jurists appointed either by Lula or former presidents who were politically aligned with him. Among other outrages, including crackdowns on free speech investigated by Congress, many were involved in the prosecution of Bolsonaro’s father, who is now serving a 27-year prison term, his exiled younger brother Eduardo, who in June was sentenced to a 50-month prison term, and other associates on questionable grounds that amount to little more than doubting that Brazil’s 2022 elections were fully above board. It is hard to imagine Brazil’s courts ruling in any way that would advance Flávio Bolsonaro’s legal petition claiming that the 2026 election was illegitimate and should be annulled.
“It really is disheartening and disgusting,” a Brazilian government official told me anonymously for fear of retaliation after the final results were announced.
For the Trump administration, the course is clear. Lula’s lawfare against the elder Bolsonaro was followed by the imposition of a 50 percent tariff on Brazilian goods and sanctions on some of Zanin’s fellow Supreme Court justices, including temporary U.S. travel bans and asset freezes. These measures were largely ignored and have obviously failed to deter Brazil’s illiberal leftist leaders beyond their accusing the U.S. of election interference.
Stronger measures are required. As U.S. policy toward Venezuela clearly showed after that country’s corrupt presidential election in 2024, the security and prosperity of the United States cannot meekly accommodate banana republics and their Havana- and Beijing-aligned leaders. They employ cheap legal tricks to manipulate democratic processes, subvert the will of their suffering people, destabilize countries in our near vicinity, and provoke migration crises that have flooded the U.S. with drugs and illegals, all while working with America’s greatest adversaries to undermine the security of the Western Hemisphere. If Flávio Bolsonaro cannot obtain justice amid Brazil’s judiciary’s chicanery, there is undoubtedly an empty cell somewhere near former Venezuelan president Nicolás Maduro’s where Lula could resume his incarceration.
